The Brooks Review

Top Posts

Leica Sofort 2June 13, 2024
Grand Seiko SBGX261February 23, 2023
Casio Duro MDV-106 Re-ReviewDecember 15, 2022

Recent Articles

  • 3G MacBook Follow-up

    After posting my [3G MacBook post](https://brooksreview.net/2011/10/3g-macbooks/) I have been getting quite a few more emails than normal. The bulk of which agree that Apple should provide such an option, but worry that it never will for various reasons. Among those reasons the most common are: the iPhone already has a personal hotspot mode, data plans…

    After posting my [3G MacBook post](https://brooksreview.net/2011/10/3g-macbooks/) I have been getting quite a few more emails than normal. The bulk of which agree that Apple should provide such an option, but worry that it never will for various reasons.

    Among those reasons the most common are: the iPhone already has a personal hotspot mode, data plans are expensive and this would add yet another data plan to pay for, and lastly that the data caps are so low such a computer is not realistic. I want to take a moment to better explain why I think all of these are poor excuses for Apple to *not* make a 3G equipped MacBook.

    ### Personal Hotspots

    The argument here is that Apple provided the personal hotspot mode on the iPhone so that it didn’t have to set about installing 3G in a MacBook.

    I disagree.

    I think the more likely reason Apple provided the personal hotspot mode is because they wanted to check the box on the feature comparison list with other smart phones. This feature of the iPhone never gets a ton of billing from Apple, likely because it is a quick fix to the deeper, more complex, problem of internet everywhere.

    The main problems with a personal hotspot mode are:

    1. It requires you to own two Apple devices. Something that Apple has been trying to stay away from doing ever since they introduced the first iPod. Take for example the fact that now, under iOS 5, a user can fully setup and restore an iPhone or iPad without the need for a computer.
    2. It is a clunky, non-seamless, system. To get hooked up you have to turn it on and then connect to it. This is not the type of solution that Apple likes.
    3. It’s a drain on the iPhone battery — something Apple goes to incredible lengths to prolong.

    The iPhone personal hotspot is a stop-gap, not a solution.

    ### Data Plans: Pricing

    Many have also commented that data plans are already pricy and the last thing Apple would want is to saddle users with yet another data plan. I largely agree with this, but I also see it as something that is mostly out of Apple’s control and thus something they would just ignore.

    While it would be ideal if you could share a data plan between your iPhone and iPad, that is simply not the case in the U.S.. I would suspect that Apple doesn’t much care about this, as the likelihood of a user having three data plans for three Apple devices is lower than most of the readers of this site suspect it is.

    I would guess that any 3G enable MacBook would have the same data plans and options as the iPad does: simple and à la carte.

    ### Data Plans: Caps

    Something that I had completely forgotten to address in my last post was my idea behind how Apple could deal with data caps for 3G toting MacBook users. If we assume that any 3G plan in the U.S. for a MacBook would only go as high as 2GB (maybe 5GB in rare cases) then it is safe to assume that this is not nearly enough bandwidth for the average user.

    Many readers wrote in about the potential for overage charges when you decide to download a movie on the go, or backup to Backblaze and other services. I think these readers missed the larger point of: this is not what a 3G MacBook would be for.

    I never meant to imply that we need a 3G MacBook so that we can go about our regular internet connected lives, I was simply saying that there is a subset of core services that we need and should be able to access anytime we want. Things like syncing files and checking websites.

    You would be hard pressed to go over a 2GB data cap if you stuck to actual work while on 3G. Still though I think there is an easier solution: create a bandwidth monitor mode in OS X.

    I would see it working like this:

    – OS X detects that a user is on 3G and automatically shuts off all known services that hog bandwidth.
    – OS X only allows user directed interject connectivity. (e.g. The users says fetch email, update Twitter, the user said go to this page.) All background internet enabled services are suspended.
    – There is a custom setting that a user can tweak to grant permission to certain apps, much in the same vein as how the current firewall or Spotlight settings work.

    The goal would be to create a version of OS X that would help to limit internet traffic while on 3G — all without interfering with how the user is directing the computer to act. I think such a solution is not only doable, but would be quite user friendly in a 3G MacBook scenario.

    ### Two Reasons Against 3G

    Demand and battery life hits to the MacBooks.

  • Sending a Message

    Marco Arment: >Even though there weren’t a lot of them sold, cutting off support less than two years after its launch (and even less time after it stopped being sold) sends a message to the other manufacturers that it’s acceptable not to care about the long-term usage of Android devices. As a nerd I would…

    Marco Arment:

    >Even though there weren’t a lot of them sold, cutting off support less than two years after its launch (and even less time after it stopped being sold) sends a message to the other manufacturers that it’s acceptable not to care about the long-term usage of Android devices.

    As a nerd I would be pissed. I have to wonder though just how many Android users even know what version of Android they are on and if there is even a new version out — let alone what features are *in* the new version.

    So yes, for nerds this probably is a huge negative — for most users? Well I doubt that most users know and care, all they know is that their phone isn’t evil. ((Clearly))

  • Patents and Stealing

    Timothy B. Lee talking about patent lawsuits between Apple and Android handset companies: >The important question isn’t whether such “stealing” occurred, it’s whether we want to live in a world where it’s illegal. Do you want to live in a world where only Apple is allowed to make phones with pinch-to-zoom capability (and dozens of…

    Timothy B. Lee talking about patent lawsuits between Apple and Android handset companies:

    >The important question isn’t whether such “stealing” occurred, it’s whether we want to live in a world where it’s illegal. Do you want to live in a world where only Apple is allowed to make phones with pinch-to-zoom capability (and dozens of other features) until 2027? I sure don’t.

    I can’t say that I disagree with him here. In fact I was just about to write a similar post. While I don’t think Apple is wrong for patenting these things and for using them in lawsuits, it’s the modus operandi for this industry right now, I think we as a society need to question what should be patentable.

    I don’t have the answer here, but perhaps we should think about what the answer *should* be.

  • Google Puts a Price on Privacy

    Sean Sperte [reflecting on the recent changes to Google searches](http://searchengineland.com/google-puts-a-price-on-privacy-98029): >It means, though, that Google’s privacy policies are being dictated by money. That can’t be a good thing. It was a matter of time.

    Sean Sperte [reflecting on the recent changes to Google searches](http://searchengineland.com/google-puts-a-price-on-privacy-98029):

    >It means, though, that Google’s privacy policies are being dictated by money. That can’t be a good thing.

    It was a matter of time.

  • Nokia Lumia 800

    I can’t speak much to the new version of Windows Phone 7, but the Lumia 800 looks like a phone that I would want to hold. And I can’t think of a better compliment to an iPhone competitor than that.

    I can’t speak much to the new version of Windows Phone 7, but the Lumia 800 looks like a phone that I would want to hold. And I can’t think of a better compliment to an iPhone competitor than that.

  • Quote of the Day: Jason Kottke

    “But then you look at the general aesthetics of OSX and iOS…I don’t know, it’s really confusing how the same company, especially one that had such strong design leadership, could produce something as beautifully spare as iOS and something as cheesy as the Game Center app.” — Jason Kottke

    “But then you look at the general aesthetics of OSX and iOS…I don’t know, it’s really confusing how the same company, especially one that had such strong design leadership, could produce something as beautifully spare as iOS and something as cheesy as the Game Center app.”

  • Meet Mike Elgan: An Idiot

    [Mike Elgan thinks](http://www.datamation.com/mobile-wireless/why-you-should-wait-for-the-iphone-5-1.html): >The truth, it turns out, is that the iPhone 4s kind of sucks. He boldly claims: >The iPhone 4s is the first stumble by Apple since the company launched the original iPhone in 2007. The rest of his article is filled with nonsense pilled atop of incorrect information. For example, Elgan states:…

    [Mike Elgan thinks](http://www.datamation.com/mobile-wireless/why-you-should-wait-for-the-iphone-5-1.html):

    >The truth, it turns out, is that the iPhone 4s kind of sucks.

    He boldly claims:

    >The iPhone 4s is the first stumble by Apple since the company launched the original iPhone in 2007.

    The rest of his article is filled with nonsense pilled atop of incorrect information. For example, Elgan states:

    >That last bit, the “reduced motion blur” is flat-out wrong. Apple claims that because they say the camera has image stabilization. But this feature is undetectable in real life.

    It doesn’t take a genius (or maybe it does) to read Apple’s tech specs page for the iPhone 4S and see that it says:

    >Video stabilization

    Note, that is not “image stabilization”, just video. Now, Elgan does note that:

    >I can’t detect any image stabilization in videos, either.

    Which is a far different statement from saying there is none. Either way he is an idiot.

    His biggest frustration with the phone is also his biggest love of the phone: Siri. Elgan states that 80% of the things he does on his phone is now with Siri, but it is still a pretty crappy phone. He also notes, in regard to Siri, that:

    >The problem is that it’s exactly what Apple says it is: an unfinished beta.

    Hmm.

    Elgan is flat out wrong, and idiotic about the iPhone 4S. You can make an argument that an iPhone 4 user should wait another year, that makes sense. But you can’t make that argument based on:

    – Siri being in beta, just as Apple says it is.
    – The camera being worse than the 4 — because it isn’t.
    – The camera not having image stabilization, like Apple never said it had.
    – iCloud, because that is an iOS 5 thing — something that iPhone 4 users get too.
    – The design of the new apps, because of the same reason as the last point.
    – The yellow screen, because this is always a complaint with new iPhones while the glue, or whatever, dries.

    In fact, Elgan’s only valid point is that the battery life isn’t as good — something I have experienced too. Mike Elgan: idiot.

  • iMessengers Be Warned

    Chuck Skoda: >If you send a text to multiple iMessage users, anyone who responds inline will have their message sent to everyone. I previously thought this was an issue with people having “Group Messaging” enabled in Settings→Messages, but apparently this functionality comes standard with iMessage. He brings up a couple of good reasons why this…

    Chuck Skoda:
    >If you send a text to multiple iMessage users, anyone who responds inline will have their message sent to everyone. I previously thought this was an issue with people having “Group Messaging” enabled in Settings→Messages, but apparently this functionality comes standard with iMessage.

    He brings up a couple of good reasons why this is a less that ideal situation. I haven’t noticed this personally, but that likely has to do with the fact that I never am involved in multi-party messages like this.

    The second point he brings up on privacy though is something that I have never thought of, and is in the same vein of why I hate people that send mass emails with the recipients all in the “to” field instead of BCC’d.

  • Gems Revisited: Fantastical 1.1 and Moom 2.3.1

    Dan Frakes does a nice job detailing some of the new features to two of my favorite and daily used little apps: Fantastical and Moom. The big addition to Fantastical is the ability to edit events in the app. Moom also has a big update: you can now have a little grid pop-up and you…

    Dan Frakes does a nice job detailing some of the new features to two of my favorite and daily used little apps: Fantastical and Moom.

    The big addition to Fantastical is the ability to edit events in the app. Moom also has a big update: you can now have a little grid pop-up and you can draw the size of the window, neat stuff.

    Both have a bunch of other adds and worth checking out if you were holding out for some odd reason.

    Frakes on one of the great new features in Moom:

    >The other big new feature is multi-window-layout snapshots. If you’ve got a favorite setup, with each program’s windows meticulously organized, you can take a snapshot of that layout and then use Moom to restore it at any time. This feature can be helpful for restoring order, but it’s also quite useful if, for example, you’ve got a Mac laptop and you regularly switch between using one display (just the laptop’s) and multiple displays (the laptop’s and an external display while at the office).

  • The $8 HBO

    Peter Kafka on the plans to turn around Netflix: >So Hastings is trying to build an $8-a-month version of HBO — a network you pay for in addition to your regular TV package, not one that replaces it. And to make that work, he doesn’t have to have everything — but he has to have…

    Peter Kafka on the plans to turn around Netflix:

    >So Hastings is trying to build an $8-a-month version of HBO — a network you pay for in addition to your regular TV package, not one that replaces it. And to make that work, he doesn’t have to have everything — but he has to have stuff you can’t get anywhere else.

    That’s a great way to frame what Netflix is trying to do, the question now is can they do it? ((On a side note: I worry for a company with a [CEO sporting a goatee](http://allthingsd.com/files/2011/06/reed-hastings.jpeg).))

  • Apple’s Latest Patent

    James Kendrick: >Apple filed for the slide to unlock patent before the original iPhone was released, and just received confirmation of the patent. That puts every Android device ever made firmly in the infringing category, should Apple choose to get nasty. Or should Apple choose defend itself against those that choose to steal from them,…

    James Kendrick:
    >Apple filed for the slide to unlock patent before the original iPhone was released, and just received confirmation of the patent. That puts every Android device ever made firmly in the infringing category, should Apple choose to get nasty.

    Or should Apple choose defend itself against those that choose to steal from them, or sue them. At the end of the day, I don’t think this patent should have been granted.

  • Netflix Market Value Shrivels

    Nick Wingfield: >In July, Netflix’s market value was over $16 billion. On Tuesday, after a bruising response to the financial results the company released late Monday, the Internet movie company lost more than $2 billion in value, bringing its total market capitalization to just over $4 billion. Clear, decisive, communication has a lot more value…

    Nick Wingfield:
    >In July, Netflix’s market value was over $16 billion. On Tuesday, after a bruising response to the financial results the company released late Monday, the Internet movie company lost more than $2 billion in value, bringing its total market capitalization to just over $4 billion.

    Clear, decisive, communication has a lot more value than people think.

  • iPads Change Economics, and Speed, of Hotel Wi-Fi

    [Speaking of crappy hotel WiFi](https://brooksreview.net/2011/10/3g-macbooks/), Joe Sharkey asks why it sucks: >Largely because of the broad use of iPads and other mobile tablets, which are heavy users of video streaming, the guest room Wi-Fi networks that most hotels thought they had brought up to standard just a few years ago are now often groaning under…

    [Speaking of crappy hotel WiFi](https://brooksreview.net/2011/10/3g-macbooks/), Joe Sharkey asks why it sucks:

    >Largely because of the broad use of iPads and other mobile tablets, which are heavy users of video streaming, the guest room Wi-Fi networks that most hotels thought they had brought up to standard just a few years ago are now often groaning under user demands.

    and:

    >The iPad represents the “final nail in the coffin” for the idea that all Internet is free, Mr. Garrison said.

    then, later:

    >“It’s about managing that bandwidth,” Mr. Garrison added. “We’re not saying that free Internet as you know it today is dead. We’re saying that a hotel owner will have to decide what free should be. I could have a free option, for a limited level of service, but charge for higher levels of demand.”

    Sounds a lot like blaming the iPad for hotels not being prepared to meet the demand. “Sir I am sorry your shower was cold, we just didn’t think everyone would be showering in the morning.”

  • Focus v. Focus

    Chase Jarvis, pro-photographer living in a great city, breaks down the difference between two types of ‘focus’ in photography — specifically in regards to the new Lytro camera.

    Chase Jarvis, pro-photographer living in a great city, breaks down the difference between two types of ‘focus’ in photography — specifically in regards to the new Lytro camera.

  • OWS’s Beef: Wall Street Isn’t Winning It’s Cheating

    Matt Taibbi wrote a great story about all the Occupy Wall Street complaints, what I find interesting is the confusion of the OWS message that he leads off the story with — [as I have said](https://brooksreview.net/2011/10/occupy-this/) this is the biggest problem of the movement, vague goals and messages. Beyond this, I love this passage by…

    Matt Taibbi wrote a great story about all the Occupy Wall Street complaints, what I find interesting is the confusion of the OWS message that he leads off the story with — [as I have said](https://brooksreview.net/2011/10/occupy-this/) this is the biggest problem of the movement, vague goals and messages. Beyond this, I love this passage by Taibbi:

    >It is virtually impossible to not make money in banking when you have unlimited access to free money, especially when the government keeps buying its own cash back from you at market rates.

    >Your average chimpanzee couldn’t fuck up that business plan, which makes it all the more incredible that most of the too-big-to-fail banks are nonetheless still functionally insolvent, and dependent upon bailouts and phony accounting to stay above water.

    Nice summation of the recession we find ourselves in.

  • HTC and Dropbox Bring Free 5GB Extra Storage to ‘All’ Android Mobiles

    Ben Crompton: >HTC has confirmed via its Twitter feed that users of all of its Android smartphones will be getting 5GB of extra memory through the Dropbox cloud storage service. If true, that’s a great deal for Android users. ((I say ‘if true’ because there seems to be some doubt as to whether “all” users…

    Ben Crompton:
    >HTC has confirmed via its Twitter feed that users of all of its Android smartphones will be getting 5GB of extra memory through the Dropbox cloud storage service.

    If true, that’s a great deal for Android users. ((I say ‘if true’ because there seems to be some doubt as to whether “all” users will get it, or just all new users.))

  • FBI to Launch Nationwide Facial Recognition Service

    This falls under the: “Cool, scary, and really we didn’t have this already?” categories. Also: CSI is a bunch of liars. ((But we already knew this.))

    This falls under the: “Cool, scary, and really we didn’t have this already?” categories. Also: CSI is a bunch of liars. ((But we already knew this.))

  • More Reason to Love Mail 5 Search

    J. Eddie Smith, IV: >Just the other day, through experimentation, I discovered that I can exclude results by adding a dash in front of search terms (like a Google search). I had no clue, great tip.

    J. Eddie Smith, IV:

    >Just the other day, through experimentation, I discovered that I can exclude results by adding a dash in front of search terms (like a Google search).

    I had no clue, great tip.

  • Japan’s Zombie Outbreak Preparedness

    Johnny Strategy: >Currently the only known way to quiet a zombie is to bash their brains in. This is a task that is difficult as it is gruesome, and only slightly easier if aided by a shotgun. However, kyonshi can be sedated by tactically placing a small scroll with buddhist inscriptions on the forehead (as…

    Johnny Strategy:

    >Currently the only known way to quiet a zombie is to bash their brains in. This is a task that is difficult as it is gruesome, and only slightly easier if aided by a shotgun. However, kyonshi can be sedated by tactically placing a small scroll with buddhist inscriptions on the forehead (as pictured above). Also, (and this helps in assisting the first objective) kyonshi are legally blind. They detect human presence from the smell of our breath, making a cornered escape realistically possible by simply holding your breath.

    All good information to know heading into Halloween.

    [via Khoi Vinh]

  • Quote of the Day: Jonathan Ive

    “You see, I think he better than anyone understood that while ideas ultimately can be so powerful, they begin as fragile, barely formed thoughts, so easily missed, so easily compromised, so easily just squished.” — Jonathan Ive

    “You see, I think he better than anyone understood that while ideas ultimately can be so powerful, they begin as fragile, barely formed thoughts, so easily missed, so easily compromised, so easily just squished.”